Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Bakers Dozen Bagel
Vegetable Tuna Salad
Tuna Salad
Chopp'd Herring Salad on a Bagel
About
Sammy's New York Bagels
If you find yourself in Scarsdale, NY, make sure to carve out a moment for Sammy's New York Bagels, where tradition meets taste in every bite. Nestled at 1461 Weaver St, this beloved local gem has earned its reputation as a must-visit destination for bagel aficionados and casual diners alike.
One of the most enchanting aspects of Sammy's is the sheer variety of bagels on offer. Each one is crafted to perfection, boasting that quintessential New York-style texture: soft, doughy, and oh-so-satisfying. Whether you opt for the classic plain or indulge in a more adventurous flavor, you're in for a treat. Customers rave about the Sammy sticks, which are bagels rolled into sticks — simple yet incredibly delicious. As one satisfied customer, David W., puts it: "Two words - Sammy sticks. Chefs kiss!"
The toppings and spreads further elevate your bagel experience. From luscious scallion cream cheese to fresh lox, the selections are both expansive and appetizing. For those looking for a heartier meal, the tuna salad and vegetable tuna salad provide satisfying options that complement the bagels seamlessly.
But let’s not forget about the drinks to accompany your breakfast or lunch. A small cup of their coffee is just $2.10, making it an affordable yet perfect pairing with your bagel choice. On weekends, the line may stretch a bit longer, but as Susan Z. points out, this speaks volumes about the freshness and quality the store delivers.
A personal favorite moment at Sammy's was munching on their famous corn muffin, which one customer, Glenn S., describes as some of the best in Westchester. Each bite reveals a moist, flavorful blend that is hard to rival, further solidifying Sammy’s reputation as a top-notch bagel shop.
The ambiance is decidedly casual with counter service, ensuring your experience is quick and efficient. Just keep in mind, it’s cash only. However, there's an ATM on-site, albeit with a transaction fee that may catch you off guard. While seating is sparse, you can easily grab your order and enjoy it alfresco or while driving home, especially with the handy Sammy sticks in tow.
In summary, Sammy's New York Bagels is more than just another bagel shop; it's a celebration of New York's rich culinary heritage. With quality bagels, fantastic spreads, and friendly service, it’s no wonder why locals adore this spot. So next time you’re in Scarsdale, don’t miss out on a truly delicious bagel experience.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ The staff, service, and especially their muffins stand out as some of the best in Westchester. For aficionados of a quality corn muffin, heading to Sammy's is imperative. ”
“ Two words - Sammy sticks. They may just be bagels rolled out into sticks with everything on them but they're just so good. Chefs kiss! ”
“ My number one bagel spot in New York. Best bagels, white fish salad, scallion cream cheese, and lox! ”
“ Sammy's has excellent, fresh bagels and lots of good things to put on them. I'm picky about bagels, and I think these are great. They are soft and doughy just like I like them. They have all different flavors. Sometimes the line can be a little long on weekends, and the store can be a little crowded, but this is a great bagel store. Parking is ample in the parking lot. They don't take credit cards. ”
“ I work at a temple in Scarsdale. So I figured there must be good bagels, right? I think the bagels are very good. They don't upcharge for bialys which is nice. Some places do. They don't charge for freezer bags which is nice. I like the Sammy's stick, which is a long straight bagel stick. Perfect for eating on the drive home. Cash only. They do have an atm which I think charges $2.75 transaction fee which seems too high. I've never tried anything but the bagels which I liked very much. No seating. Counter service. Fast friendly efficient. Clean. ”
“ Great kosher New York bagels for this Philadelphian! They know what they're doing so they only have bagels, baked goods, cream cheese, fish, coffee, and drinks. Quick service too! Just know there is no seating though there is a counter by the window and there is no washing station for my fellow yidden out there. ”
